I bought a Red-trimmed Tallit. It is pretty-much as seen on the picture, however mine did not come with the promised maching Sash.
The quality of the material is very good. Hardy Cotton.
This garment is not really a modern adaptation. It seems pretty much like a peasant would wear in ancient Isreal. So, in that sence, maybe it is like the one our Messiah wore, but not modern. Certainly not modern enough to wear every-day.
At least this garment is a good example of what they would have worn and a good basis for those interested in making their own. A good model to use.
Would I buy another one? No.
Would I recommend to a friend? Yes.